Your privacy

The LyceumCognitive Behavioural Therapy
The hidden economics of therapy and insurance fee caps

Perspective

A note on what this is: this is an opinion piece. It raises questions I have sat with for years, from inside the profession.

Who Does Your Insurer Actually Let You See?

By Sanah Younis, Founder and Clinical Director of The Lyceum Clinic · The Lyceum, West London

Why are some therapists not on my insurance approved list?

Insurers set a maximum fee they will pay a therapist. To appear on the approved list, a therapist must agree to work at or below that cap. Many experienced, senior clinicians cannot run a sustainable practice at those rates, so they are not on the list. The list is shaped by economics, not by clinical suitability. Most members are never told this.

Sanah Younis, Founder and Clinical Director of The Lyceum Clinic and a BABCP accredited CBT therapist, The Lyceum Clinic

Sanah Younis

BABCP accredited Cognitive Behavioural Psychotherapist

When you use your private health insurance to find a therapist, you are handed a list of approved names and told, in effect, choose from these. It feels like choice. It looks like a service being done for you.

Here is the question almost no one thinks to ask. Why are those particular therapists on the list, and who is missing from it? The answer is not clinical. It is economic. And once you see it, you cannot unsee it.

The cap nobody mentions

Private health insurers set a maximum fee they will pay a therapist. To appear on the approved list, a therapist has to agree to work at or below that cap. That figure is often well below the standard rate an experienced, accredited private therapist would ordinarily charge.

Sit with what that means for a moment.

The list you are given is not, and cannot be, a list of the most experienced or most suitable therapists for you. It is a list of the therapists willing, or financially able, to work for that amount. Those are not the same thing. Many of the most experienced clinicians I know simply cannot run a sustainable practice at those rates, so they are not on the list at all.

Which leads to an uncomfortable conclusion. The people relying on insurance to access therapy, often the people who most need skilled help, are quietly steered away from some of the very clinicians best placed to help them. Not by any judgement about clinical fit. By a fee cap they were never told existed.

"The list is not a list of the most experienced therapists for you. It is a list of the therapists willing, or financially able, to work for that amount."

The fairness question

I want to be careful and fair, so I will put these as questions rather than accusations.

Insurers are large, commercially successful businesses. Employers pay considerable sums to provide cover to their staff. Within a system that moves that much money, is it fair that the fee reaching the therapist actually delivering the care, the person in the room doing the emotionally demanding work, is held so low?

And is it fair to you, the member, never to be told that your pool of choice has been narrowed on economic rather than clinical grounds?

There is a knock on effect that troubles me most as a clinician. When a therapist is paid a capped, low fee, the only way to make a living is volume. More clients, more back to back sessions, less room to breathe between the weight of one person's story and the next. I have watched skilled, dedicated colleagues stretched to the point where their own wellbeing frays, and I do not believe that can be hidden from the work. A depleted therapist is not a bargain. It is a quietly worse outcome for everyone, the clinician and the client alike.

The economics of private therapy and insurance in the UK

Why you rarely hear therapists say this

You might reasonably wonder why, if this is so widely felt inside the profession, you almost never hear it said aloud.

In my experience, many therapists are simply afraid to speak. They worry, rightly or wrongly, that questioning the terms of a large insurer could cost them their place on the approved list, and with it a meaningful part of their livelihood. So the terms are accepted, quietly.

I want to be clear about what that silence is, and is not. It is not agreement. It is the caution of people who feel they cannot afford to speak, and it is one reason this conversation has never really been had in the open, where members like you might hear it.

The other road, and its own trap

So an independent therapist faces two options. Accept the insurer's terms, and the volume pressure that comes with them. Or step away from insurance altogether and work privately.

But stepping away leads into a different squeeze. The private space is increasingly shaped by well funded, venture backed therapy platforms, the "Uber of therapy" model, which can outspend an independent practitioner many times over on advertising. They buy up the visibility. So an experienced independent therapist, without a marketing budget to match, is starved of the attention that would connect them to the people who need them. The result rhymes with the first problem: excellent clinicians made harder to find, and members funnelled towards whoever has the deepest marketing pockets, rather than the best fit for them.

The question I am left with

Put it together and an uncomfortable picture emerges. On one side, fee caps that quietly limit who you are allowed to see and squeeze the therapists who accept them. On the other, a private market where budget, more than merit, increasingly decides who you can even find.

In both, the same thing is at risk of being lost: your access to the right, experienced clinician, and the survival of the independent practitioner trying to provide it.

I do not have a tidy solution to offer you. I am not sure anyone does. But I have come to believe the economics deserve daylight, because the people making one of the most important decisions of their lives, who to trust with their mental health, are making it inside a system whose rules they were never shown.

"When you were handed that list of approved therapists, did anyone tell you who was left off it, and why?"

I did not write this to sell you anything. I wrote it because I think you deserve to understand how the system you are trusting actually works. If you would like to understand your own options clearly, including how to use your cover well and what it does and does not limit, I am always happy to talk it through honestly. And if this resonated, or if you see it differently, I would genuinely like to hear from you.

Sanah

Further reading

Talk it through honestly, free 15 minute call

Face to face in Chiswick, Ealing and Richmond, or online across the UK.

People also ask

Written by Sanah Younis, Founder and Clinical Director of The Lyceum Clinic

Related articles

Sanah Younis, Founder and Clinical Director of The Lyceum Clinic and a BABCP accredited CBT therapist

About the author

Sanah Younis

Founder and Clinical Director · BABCP Accredited no. 1000792

Sanah Younis is the Founder and Clinical Director of The Lyceum Clinic and a BABCP accredited Cognitive Behavioural Therapist. The practice offers evidence based CBT, ACT, and Compassion Focused Therapy for anxiety, OCD, depression, burnout, and neurodivergence.

She writes about the clinical and human side of therapy: what the evidence actually shows, what she observes in her consulting room, and what she wishes more people understood before they arrive. Her writing is sourced, honest about uncertainty, and written in the belief that good information is itself a form of care.

From the clinic

Writing worth reading, when it matters.

Occasional articles from Sanah on anxiety, OCD, depression, and the practical side of therapy. No marketing, no weekly digest. Only when there is something worth saying.

No spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Your data is held securely and never shared.

Frequently asked questions

Does using insurance limit which therapist I can see?

Yes. Insurers only pay therapists who have agreed to their fee structure. This quietly narrows your pool of choice on economic rather than clinical grounds, and most members are never told this is happening.

Can I see a therapist not on my insurance list?

Yes. You can choose to see any therapist privately, paying the standard rate yourself. Some people use a health cash plan to reclaim part of the cost.

BABCP accredited · Chiswick & online · Check availability

Start with a conversation