Your privacy

The LyceumCognitive Behavioural Therapy

The Lyceum · Clinical Insights

The Dangers of EMDR: What the Scary Stories Get Right, and What They Miss

Sanah Younis
Sanah Younis

BABCP Accredited CBT Therapist

·

·

6 min read

A contemplative painting in deep blues of a woman sitting quietly in profile with a calm black cat beside her, used for a Sanah Younis reflection on EMDR, side effects and safety

The search behind the fear

If you have just read a forum post titled 'EMDR ruined my life,' I completely understand why you are terrified to step into my room. I want to validate that fear immediately: those stories are not made up. They describe a very real, horrific experience of being re traumatised by a therapy that was supposed to heal them. It happens, and it breaks my heart as a clinician. But it does not happen because EMDR is inherently dangerous; it happens because the preparation phase was skipped or rushed.

What is actually happening in the brain

Here is what is actually happening in the brain. EMDR is designed to deliberately open up a closed, infected wound so we can finally clean it out. Because we are opening the wound, it is completely normal to feel 'stirred up' between our early processing sessions. You might have more vivid dreams, sudden flashes of emotion, or feel physically exhausted. I call this the 'EMDR hangover.' It is the feeling of your brain actively working to digest the trauma, and it usually settles within 24 to 48 hours.

Why preparation comes first

However, the harm you read about online almost always stems from a therapist starting that processing work too early, before the client has any 'brakes.' In my room, we spend weeks, sometimes months, just building your brakes. We install safe places, containment exercises, and grounding techniques. We do not touch the trauma until I know, without a shadow of a doubt, that you can safely return to the present moment.

EMDR is not something I 'do to you' while you endure it; it is a collaborative healing process, and we only ever move at the exact speed your nervous system can handle.

The accompanying clinical guide sets out the evidence on EMDR safety, the temporary effects some people notice, who it may not suit, and how safety is built in.

Read the clinical guide

If you are in immediate danger or cannot stay safe, call 999 or go to A&E. For urgent mental health support in England that is not an emergency, contact 111. Samaritans are available on 116 123. This is a personal clinical reflection, not a diagnosis or a substitute for individual assessment.

If reading about EMDR has left you unsure, an initial conversation can help you decide. Book a free consultation.

Related reading

Articles on the same subject.

Clinical guides and evidence based reading selected for this topic.

Frequently Asked

Questions, answered plainly.

Ready to begin?

If reading about EMDR has left you unsure, an initial conversation can help you decide.

Sanah Younis, Founder and Clinical Director of The Lyceum Clinic and a BABCP accredited CBT therapist

About the author

Sanah Younis

Founder and Clinical Director · BABCP Accredited no. 1000792

Sanah Younis is the Founder and Clinical Director of The Lyceum Clinic and a BABCP accredited Cognitive Behavioural Therapist. The practice offers evidence based CBT, ACT, and Compassion Focused Therapy for anxiety, OCD, depression, burnout, and neurodivergence.

She writes about the clinical and human side of therapy: what the evidence actually shows, what she observes in her consulting room, and what she wishes more people understood before they arrive. Her writing is sourced, honest about uncertainty, and written in the belief that good information is itself a form of care.

If this is useful, you can get Sanah's next reflection sent straight to you.

No marketing. No weekly digest. Only when there is something worth saying. Unsubscribe at any time.

Frequently asked questions

Is EMDR dangerous?

EMDR is a recommended, evidence based treatment for post traumatic stress disorder and is generally well tolerated when delivered by a trained therapist after assessment. Some people notice temporary effects such as vivid dreams or a short lived increase in distress in the early stages, which usually settle. Whether it is appropriate for one person is decided at assessment.

Can EMDR make you worse?

Some people notice a temporary increase in distress, vivid dreams or tiredness between early sessions as processing continues, and this usually settles as the work progresses. Preparation, pacing and a trained therapist are there to manage this, and persistent effects should be raised with the therapist so the plan can be adjusted.

What are the side effects of EMDR?

Commonly described temporary effects include vivid or unusual dreams, tiredness, heightened emotion and a short lived rise in distress or reminders between early sessions. These are usually time limited, and an assessment considers what to expect in a particular case.

Why do some people say EMDR ruined their life?

Difficult experiences are most often linked to memory processing being started too early, too fast, or without adequate preparation, grounding and assessment. Recognised EMDR practice builds in a preparation phase and paces the work, which is designed to reduce exactly this risk.

BABCP accredited · Chiswick & online · Check availability

Start with a conversation